Skip to main content

Barrett's: A look back and a look inside Batavia's oldest outdoor store

By JIM NIGRO

That's Mike Barrett pictured at the counter of Barrett's Batavia Marine. His father, the late Dave Barrett, sold me Remington 870 when I was 17. Knowing it was my first shotgun, he threw in a box of shells, #5 pheasant loads. Not long afterward, I purchased my first wild game cookbook. While those are two of my earliest memories of Barrett's, they are far from the first.

Barrett's was founded in 1954 by brothers Dave and Charlie Barrett. At that time, my visits to the west end of the city were either to John Castronova's Redtop for char-broiled Arpeko hot dogs or to Flavorite Farms for ice cream.

Mike Barrett has seen the numerous changes through the years and he easily recalls the wide-open spaces on the west end and the mere handful of businesses in operation then.

Not only are those establishments gone, so too are the wide-open spaces.

Today, despite the crowded surroundings and the fast-paced world around them, Barrett's remains a favorite among the outdoor crowd.

In addition to hunting and fishing gear and outdoor wear, Barrett's is still the place to take an outboard in need of repair, have a gun barrel reblued or have the eyelets on a favorite fishing rod repaired.

As might be expected, members of the sporting community don't always enter the store intent on making a purchase. Oftentimes they simply need input and advice, whether it be hunting and fishing tips, tactics, equipment care or legal aspects of their sport.

And that hasn't changed over the years. I'd be remiss if I failed to mention some of Barrett's employees who provided helpful insight in days gone by -- people like Bob Smith (now City of Batavia Animal Control Officer), Danny Carmichael and the late Paul Levins, each of whom supplied countless people with conscientious service and answers to their questions.  

Above is Jack Taylor, Genesee County Chapter president of SCOPE (Shooters Committee on Political Education). A 20-year employee with Barrett's, Jack is much like his predecessors at the store -- he's eager to assist customers.

John Lawrence, angler, hunter and former trap-and-skeet All-American, looks over a shotgun he had refinished.

Evidently, he's pleased with the results.

That's Jim Quartley perusing the aisles. He's been frequenting Barrett's since he was old enough to peddle a two-wheeler. Any fishing equipment he purchased in those early years was immediately tested in the waters of Tonawanda Creek.

Warsaw trapper Gary Smith looks over the store's inventory. He said he'll be putting out sets for mink, muskrat and beaver this season.

I've enjoyed a memorable outing or two with this guy in days gone by...He's avid trapper, waterfowler and noted flyfishermen, Ron Wickings.

In addition to his ability as a gunsmith, Mike Barrett is up to date on outdoor policy and changes that affect the outdoorsmen of New York State. Here he briefly reflects on recent issues concerning the outdoor scene. 

A customer checks out the merchandise on the used gun rack...and it brought back memories. I purchased my first rifle from that same rack in the late '60s, a Winchester 225. It was the aforementioned Bob Smith who sighted that gun in for me -- he had it dead-on at 150 yards.

It's a pity that neither of this pair cares to bring a camera afield -- if either one had ever kept a journal of their outdoor exploits it would have made a great sportsmen's anthology.

This painting on Barrett's wall reflects the atmosphere of the store itself, capturing an earlier time, when the covers of outdoor magazines weren't glossy photos, but graced with the work of gifted artists, people who created settings that captured the imagination of young outdoorsmen.

The men who walked into the store on this day -- and others like them -- have spent a good part of their life enjoying such settings, be it cattails or woodlots, field or stream. And their adventures often began with a stop at Barrett's.

Ron C Welker

Thanks Jim,
Long over due kudos for Mike and the store, it is today as in the passed a landmark in Batavia, always a smiling face to greet customers and good service. It is also good to hear the names of almost famous people of the passed, Dave, Paul, and of course Danny with the great service / advice that they provided.
I purchased my first centerfire rifle there, Win. Model 70 .243 followed by many, I just reciently added from the store my first lever gun . Always felt at home shopping in the store or just wandering around checking out the used gun racks, seems like conversation was always going on about all the things you might be interested in, hunting, shooting , fishing etc.
Ron

Dec 23, 2011, 3:32pm Permalink
Eric [Rick] von kramer

I bought my first gun, a Remington model 11 from the Big store on the little street,[ how many people know where i mean] but after that it was always Barretts,,, Hey ron how's it goin?

Dec 23, 2011, 4:12pm Permalink
JIM NIGRO

Ron - thanks for your comments, and here's hoping Barrett's withstands another fifty- plus years of change.......Merry Christmas!

Dec 23, 2011, 8:24pm Permalink
Ron C Welker

Rick,
Merry Christmas to you and the family. I posted a note in your guest book, talk to you soon.
Ron

I was going to guess Salway's as I purchased arrows there a while ago (seems just like yesterday), just couldnt remember them selling guns untill I slept on it :>) Did Jim win anything?

Dec 24, 2011, 9:14am Permalink
Jeff Waterman

I still have the fishing reel my Dad bought here circa 1972 for my birthday. I remember we got the rod at Salway's (still have it, too) and the reel at the Marine, where they also filled the spool for me. You don't get custom spool filling at the big box stores.

Dec 24, 2011, 11:04am Permalink

Authentically Local