Batavia simply didn't work out for Coffee Culture, said Perry Ouzounis, VP of operations for the chain's corporate parent.
"There's no doubt about it, it's never an easy decision to close a store, but the market there wasn't very strong for us," Ouzounis said.
The Batavia closing was one of three Coffee Culture locations in WNY that closed last week, Ouzounis said, but other locations, including in Buffalo and Erie, Pa., as well as locations in Canada and Florida, continue to do well.
The closure of the Batavia store last week was big news, garnering a substantial number of page views to The Batavian's initial report of the signs being removed from the building. The coffee shop did seem popular, at least to some extent, in Batavia.
"Of course, I'm not prepared to share our P&L," Ouzounis said. "It just wasn't a viable location for us."
When the shop first opened, the company was actively seeking a franchisee to take over operations, but in two years, no potential owner stepped forward.
Ouzounis said it's tough letting their employees go, but they are receiving all pay due and other separation benefits.
"We are doing the right thing within state law," Ouzounis said.
Ouzounis said Coffee Culture is not finished growing and will look for new opportunties for new stores, but that, "unfortunately," Batavia wasn't meeting the company's goals for "long-term success."