Local Matters

Community Sponsors

March 28, 2011 - 5:58pm

Only two of six potential sites for vets cemetery are in Genesee County

posted by Howard B. Owens in Le Roy, Bethany, Charles Schumer, Veteran's Cemetery.

After much talk about the need to locate a new veterans' cemetery close to Batavia, only two potential sites announced today by Sen. Charles Schumer are in Genesee County.

Three sites are in Alden and one is in Akron.

The two potential sites in Genesee County are in Le Roy and East Bethany.

Schumer was in Batavia on March 7 to announce his plans to fast track the construction of a cemetery, ideally close to Batavia since it's centrally located between Rochester and Buffalo.

Currently, the closest veterans' cemetery to either city is in Bath.

Officials from the Department of Veterans Affairs are expected to visit the six potential sites this week.

The exact locations were not released.

The sites were identified after the VA solicited proposals from area landowners willing to sell at least 200 acres of land to the government

“I have long fought for this veterans' cemetery in Western New York to become a reality, and today’s news that the VA will be visiting six potential cemetery sites in Western New York is an important step towards finally finding a suitable resting place for Western New York vets,” Schumer said in a statement.

Full press release after the jump:

Today, U.S. Senator Charles E. Schumer announced that the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) plans to visit six potential veterans cemetery sites this week in Western New York: three sites in Alden, one site in Akron, one site in Leroy, and one site in East Bethany.  The six sites were generated from the VA’s Expression of Interest solicitation which was issued earlier this year.  Earlier this month, Schumer wrote a letter to Secretary Shinseki of the VA, urging that the VA establish a firm timeline for completion of the long overdue veterans’ cemetery in Western New York, specifically in choosing the cemetery site. The VA has yet to acquire the necessary land for the cemetery, further delaying the design and building phase that will ultimately lead to a suitable resting place for Western New York veterans. Today’s announcement marks a step in the right direction towards bringing a long overdue cemetery to over 200,000 veterans in Western New York.

“I have long fought for this veterans cemetery in Western New York to become a reality, and today’s news that the VA will be visiting six potential cemetery sites in Western New York is an important step towards finally finding a suitable resting place for Western New York vets,” Schumer said. “After everything the many thousands of veterans in this region have done for us, it is imperative that they have a local resting place where they can receive the honor they deserve.”
VA National Cemetery officials announced that they will be in Buffalo on Wednesday, March 30th,  to conduct site visits at 6 potential cemetery sites within the VA’s target area in WNY. This target area is the area 7 miles to the North and south of the Thruway, and about 20 miles to the East and West of the Town of Pembroke in Genesee County. The six locations being assessed are three sites in Alden, one site in Akron, one site in Leroy, and one site in East Bethany.  These six potential sites were generated from the VA’s Expression of Interest solicitation which was issued in January 2011.

In a March 7th letter to Secretary Shinseki of the VA, Schumer wrote, “There are some 200,000 veterans in the Buffalo-Rochester region who are not served by a national cemetery.  They have waited too long for this important project and they have been disturbed by a lack of information and communications with the VA.  I urge you to ensure timely progress in selecting and developing a site, and I request that a firm schedule for the project be established and shared with the community.” In today’s announcement, the VA outlined the firm schedule that Schumer had strongly lobbied for. During the VA’s visits to each location,  the officials will assess which sites best fit the VA’s criteria, which includes factors such as the site’s topography, access to highways, proximity to wetlands, and the impact of neighboring facilities. After this assessment is complete, the VA will rank and score each site as part of its evaluation process.  The VA will then narrow the field of candidate sites to the top two and will  proceed with a more detailed due diligence analysis.  The VA anticipates that this review will continue for most of this year.  If it proceeds accordingly, the VA would then be on track to acquire the 200-acres of property by the end of this year or the Spring of 2012.  The VA will then hire an architectural/engineering firm to help develop the master plan for the site, clearing the way for construction.

There are currently six National Cemeteries in New York State, but the facility in Bath is the only one in all of Central New York, Western New York, the Southern Tier and the Rochester Finger Lakes Region.  Current VA regulations allow for establishment of a new cemetery when it would serve 80,000 or more veterans within a 75 mile area. In Western New York alone there are approximately 125,000 veterans. Combined with the Rochester area, which is also more than 75 miles away from the nearest national cemetery in Bath, there are more than 200,000 veterans without appropriate access to a cemetery. A cemetery location in Western New York not only makes sense, but would fulfill an urgent need of these veterans.

Veterans Affairs began seeking a cemetery site in August 2010, with the effort focused within a 50 mile diameter area which included parts of Ontario, Canada, Lake Erie, Erie County, Orleans County, Niagara County and Genesee county. In January 2011, the VA announced that they were starting over and had moved the area under consideration to the east and would center it in Genesee County. Today’s announcement means that these milestones in the process will not continued to be pushed back.

Schumer has long argued that it is critical for the veterans cemetery location to be decided on and for building to begin immediately.  Half of New York Veterans are 65 years of age or older, and now is the time to start planning for the future of those veterans, and ensuring that they are treated with the honor they deserve.  Schumer has heard from local veterans groups that veterans in Western New York desperately want to be buried in a national shrine, but don’t want to force their families to travel long distances to visit, potentially at great hardship to do so.

Today, there are more than 22 million veterans who are eligible for the honor of burial in a National Cemetery. Veterans with discharges other than dishonorable, their spouses and dependent children may be eligible for burial in a VA national cemetery. Those who die on active duty may also be buried in a national cemetery.

Andrew Lathan
Andrew Lathan's picture
Last seen: 7 years 5 months ago
Joined: Jun 20 2009 - 5:21pm
Lets hope the Town of LeRoy gets it together and has the welcome wagon out in full force this week.
Amy Tannehill-Joyner
Amy Tannehill-Joyner's picture
Last seen: 6 years 5 months ago
Joined: Aug 1 2009 - 9:23pm
I still think NYS has the answer.. "right in our own backyard". They own the old John White Game Farm.. >200 Acres, and ready now. Why isn't senator Schumer looking at that?
Jeff Waterman
Jeff Waterman's picture
Last seen: 2 years 4 months ago
Joined: Mar 9 2011 - 8:02pm
The whole idea of confiscating the John White Game Farm apparently started in 2004 when Charlie Nesbitt started the push to turn it into a cemetery. More recently the GCEDC has been trying to obtain portions of it for their STAMP project. While it perhaps is underutilized by sportsmen, it does indeed host dog trials, handicapped hunting, youth hunts, has grasslands for pheasant and other game, and is used for other sporting and conservation activities. The John White Farm was acquired and maintained with conservation money, some of which from the federal Pittman-Robertson Fund. These conservation lands cannot just be taken away and used for other purposes without serious ramifications. The only way this can happen (properly) is to get permission from DEC, get approval from the State Legislature (and maybe federal approval also), and REPLACE this land with other land of equal or greater conservation and habitat potential. Failure to go this route would then lead to New York State forfeiting their share of Pittman-Robertson money (somewhere around $10 Million annually). Note that Pittman-Roberson money comes from a tax on sporting equipment, so it is paid by the sportsmen, and not coming from the general fund While we should honor our veterans and see that they have a proper cemetery, bear in mind that many fought and died to prevent things like abusive governments from just taking away property to do with whatever the current regime sees fit.
dennis wight
dennis wight's picture
Last seen: 1 month 2 days ago
Joined: May 4 2008 - 9:33pm
Nice, Jeff!!!
JoAnne Rock
JoAnne Rock's picture
Last seen: 7 years 4 days ago
Joined: Mar 10 2010 - 7:49am
Very informative post, Jeff.
Jeremiah Pedro
Jeremiah Pedro's picture
Last seen: 6 years 4 months ago
Joined: Feb 17 2010 - 9:27am
Good post Jeff.

Post new comment

Log in or register to post comments



Copyright © 2008-2020 The Batavian. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

blue button