Local Matters

Community Sponsors

September 12, 2014 - 2:52pm

Lawsuit blames security miscue at Kid Rock concert for Jason McNeil's catastrophic injuries

If Craig Lawson had been properly escorted from the concert venue the night Kid Rock played Darien Lake a year ago July, alleges a Buffalo attorney, he never would have been able to deliver a devastating, life-altering sucker punch to Jason McNeil.

The punch took away the life Jason and his wife Pamela and their two children once knew in Tuscaloosa, Ala.

McNeil, 44, needs constant care after suffering serious head trauma as a result of the punch.

And he wasn't even Lawson's intended victim.

A federal lawsuit filed on behalf of the McNeils will attempt to determine to what degree concert promoter Live Nation and concert host Darien Lake Theme Park is responsible for that punch.

The McNeils are seeking $150 million in damages.

The suit alleges other factors that contributed to McNeil's injuries, said attorney Donald Chiari, but at the heart of it is how Live Nation security handled Lawson after the decision had been made to eject him from the venue for being drunk and disorderly.

Lawson was taken to the concert venue gate (possibly the one known as South PAC), but the guard never completed the task of actually getting Lawson out the gate, Chiari said. If he had, there were security guards in place to keep him out of the venue.

There also would have been a fence between Lawson and the VIP gate, where McNeil was exiting the concert with Pamela.

While a Live Nation guard was taking Lawson to the gate, a person he had been in a confrontation with Lawson inside the venue was supposed to be leaving through the VIP gate.

That person wasn't McNeil.

With Lawson allegedly left unattended for a couple of minutes inside the concert venue, the 34-year-old Canadian ran over to the VIP gate, and in a case of mistaken identity, cold-cocked McNeil.

The punch delivered to a person he had no prior contact with is a fact Lawson admitted during his sentencing Aug. 18. He's currently serving a year in the Genesee County Jail on the assault charge.

McNeil was knocked out before his head hit the ground. He was in a coma by the time he arrived via Mercy Flight to ECMC and has required several surgeries and extended hospitalization since. He has suffered loss of speech; ability to read and write; and comprehend what people are saying; and the ability to walk.

The same security guard who allegedly failed to get Lawson out of the gate was one of the first on scene after the punch was thrown, Chiari said.

"The guard got there and said, 'Oh, my God, I was just throwing you out two-and-half minutes ago,' Chiari said, "that's literally in his statement."

It's not unusual -- as anybody knows who regularly reads arrest reports from concerts at Darien Lake -- for patrons to be ejected from the venue and then later try to return. There are frequent trespassing arrests at Darien Lake concerts. 

Chiari said the unique issue in this case is the alleged failure to follow through on getting a disorderly patron out of the concert venue so other patrons are properly protected.

"No premise's owner or any security is an absolute insurer of safety of third parties, but they still have to do what is reasonable," Chiari said.

The suit names as defendants Live Nation in its at least 10 various incorporations, Darien Lake (by three different corporate names), Craig Lawson, and the company, Contemporary Services Corporation, Live Nation contracts with for security personnel and training.

Not named in the suit is Kid Rock or the Genesee County Sheriff's Office.

Chiari said there is no plan to include the county in the suit.  

Live Nation pays for Sheriff's deputies to provide law enforcement on concert nights, but deputies do not enter the concert venue and from Chiari's description of events, it appears everything leading up to the punch happened within the venue.

The Washington Post recently published a story about the growing rowdiness and disorderly behavior at country music concerts nationally. It's not just a Darien Lake thing. Many contemporary music acts seem to encourage excessive drinking and concerts are often preceded by tailgate parties were copious amounts of booze are consumed.

The suit also names as co-defendants SMG Food and Beverage, and Aramark Sports and Entertainment Services, stating those companies were the vendors of alcoholic beverages the night of the concert. The suit alleges the vendors unlawfully sold alcohol to an already intoxicated Craig Lawson.

This afternoon, The Batavian requested comment from both Live Nation and Darien Lake and have not as of yet received a response.

UPDATE: This from a spokesperson with Live Nation: "We cannot comment on pending litigation."

UPDATE: We received this from Darien Lake: "Darien Lake confirms that on August 29, a civil lawsuit was filed by the family of Jason McNeil. As a matter of policy, we cannot comment on pending litigation." - Rod Rankin, General Manager, Darien Lake

robin neyman
robin neyman's picture
Last seen: 1 year 2 months ago
Joined: May 21 2010 - 8:06am

Why don't they start thinking about not selling alcohol inside the venues!!!! But then again they would lose a lot more money if they did what should be done!!!!

cj sruger
cj sruger's picture
Last seen: 1 year 2 months ago
Joined: Jun 18 2009 - 12:04pm

lets just ban concerts, Not sure how live nation is liable for this, however they probably are the only ones to sue that have 150 $million. This guy punched someone and they were seriously injured thats what happened. kind of an isolated incident, move along now

Lorie Cook
Lorie Cook's picture
Last seen: 1 year 11 months ago
Joined: Jun 26 2009 - 8:16am

Live Nation sells the tickets and it is my understanding they have their own security at the events.

Lorie Cook
Lorie Cook's picture
Last seen: 1 year 11 months ago
Joined: Jun 26 2009 - 8:16am

LOL, Robin. Drive out there some time when there is a big concert. Kids bring coolers through the swamps into the parking lot. I have seen the idiots. Security is always chasing them off. You cannot make stupid illegal.

tom hunt
tom hunt's picture
Last seen: 7 hours 13 min ago
Joined: Jan 31 2009 - 9:08am

Concerts and Bills football games are the two opportunities for grown adults or near adults to act like kids again by getting roaring drunk and causing mayhem.

Ed Hartgrove
Ed Hartgrove's picture
Last seen: 11 months 2 weeks ago
Joined: Dec 20 2012 - 11:54am

Y'all are right. Bills football games and concerts are ba-a-a-ddd! They both should be banned. And... ..and, firemen's picnics. I hear some people get pretty obnoxious and drunk there. Surely, THEY should go by the wayside. And wedding receptions. Whooooeee! Some of those can be downright ripsnorters. I say ban all receptions. An... an... and, let's not forget when uncle Walt and aunt Sadie get together for their bocce ball games. Ol' Wally sure can get loud when he ties one on, huh?

He-e-e-yyy! Why not ban alcohol? That will solve our ills.

Smoking? Banned, check!
Alcohol? Banned, check!
Celebrations? Banned, check!
Sex? Banned, che..... HEY!! YOU TWO IN THE VW! STOP THAT!!

Post new comment

Log in or register to post comments



Copyright © 2008-2019 The Batavian. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

blue button