Skip to main content

A Question of Sidewalks

By Jennifer Keys

I'm very curious to know your thoughts on sidewalks.

What do you think about sidewalks? What do sidewalks say about a community? Are some sidewalks more important than others? What is your favorite kind of a sidewalk (slate, brick, cement, dirt path...)?

Bea McManis

Jennifer,
As a child, I really didn't care. A dirt path was fine.
But, as a child, I wasn't concerned about snow removal, etc.
As a young mother, cement sidewalks were a Godsend. They made pushing a stroller or buggy easy. Easy, that is, until one encountered broken or heaved walks. It was safer to walk on a sidewalk than in the street.
Now, as a senior, walks are a must. I don't like walking in the street (just like someone else mentioned, I was someone who had a car purposely come at me while walking - it is a scary event). Once again, broken or heaved walks pose a particular threat to seniors. Walks not shoveled are also a hazard. It isn't safe for someone using a walker or in a motorized scooter walking on a heavily traveled street because sidewalks aren't cleared.
So, for me, the short answer is cement sidewalks not only for the safety issue but they add a great deal to the sense of community.

Nov 12, 2009, 7:41am Permalink
Wayne Speed

I like sidewalks. They achieve their purpose of keeping me out of the roadway when I am walking. If they are not cleaned in the winter - they become useless and force me into the street. Concrete is the overall best material in my view except that when ice forms on concrete it can be very hazardous and sneaky. Icy sidewalks are not usually icy all over. As one walks along some sections are perfectly good to walk on but then you set your weight down on a patch with ice.

Why is it that in the village of Oakfield, where I live, people insist on walking in the street when there are perfectly good sidewalks? Especially adults who really should know better.

Nov 12, 2009, 8:23am Permalink
Lorie Longhany

I absolutely love the few slate sidewalks that are left on your street, Jennifer. For me they are a little taste of local history.

Bea made some very important points about sidewalk safety.

Nov 12, 2009, 9:05am Permalink
Jennifer Keys

Great comments, I'm looking forward to more as the day progresses.

I love the slate sidewalks too, but I have to admit that they are far more slippery than anything else I've encountered.

I used to work in a classroom at St. Joseph's Villa of Rochester. I lived in the City of Rochester and could never understand why people walked in the road during nice weather. One day I asked the kids in my classroom and they told me that those people just weren't smart (though they didn't say it quite as nicely :) ). I think, though, that it is a question that we should continue to ask.

I think sidewalk shifts are hard to control because of the nature of the earth and I think many of them shift due to tree roots growing under them. It is important, though, to figure out how to make them more accessible to everyone.

Additional question:
What do you think about broken, crumbling sidewalks?

Nov 12, 2009, 10:13am Permalink
robert fazio

i think sidewalks are necessary. it is hard for older people like myself to walk in the road. it is also much safer for children who walk to school and to school activities.

Nov 12, 2009, 2:26pm Permalink
John Roach

Many people around Batavia walk in the street becuase the sidewalks are broken and/or uneven.

Sidewalk repair was done by the City and the bill was added to your property taxes until it was paid for, or you could hire somebody to do it.

Then City Council told everyone they would no longer charge you for the repiar, and the city also stopped fixing them. That's what you get for "free".

Nov 12, 2009, 3:25pm Permalink

Right on John.

I like the the plain cement sidewalks, although I am a fan of when they stain the cement certain colors, like what they did in Oakfeild.

Overall, even and not broken with weeds coming through would be the most ideal right now.

Nov 12, 2009, 3:39pm Permalink
Jennifer Keys

These are great comments. Thank you.

In addition to making it difficult to walk; what do you think ill maintained sidewalks say about a community?
In your opinion, who should maintain the sidewalks when they fall into disrepair?

They stained the cement in different colors? I haven't seen that. I will have to take a drive out that way to check it out. Sounds pretty.

Nov 12, 2009, 9:04pm Permalink

I think it shows poorly on a communtiy. How can you say you are a thriving area, if you neighborhoods look run down. Sidewalks are very much apart of that!

I have no problem replacing my sidewalk. I think the problem is that many people will not. We are too afraid to hold homeowners accountable for the condition of their homes. It costs alot of money to be a homeowner and it is hard sometimes, but that is choice that we make.

Nov 13, 2009, 11:04am Permalink
Jennifer Keys

So, Phil, are you saying that property owners (home/business) own the public sidewalks in front of their buildings? Or are you talking about the ones, such as at a home, that lead from the public sidewalk to the building, or driveway to the building?

Nov 13, 2009, 1:32pm Permalink

Authentically Local