During an altercation with a criminal suspect at Batavia Downs shortly before 1 a.m. on Sunday, a Sheriff's Office sergeant became unresponsive and, despite life-saving attempts by Batavia Downs security staff, was later pronounced dead by the Genesee County Coroner.
Thomas A. Sanfratello, 54, was a 32-year veteran of the Sheriff's Office. He was working a special assignment detail at the Batavia Downs while on duty.
The investigation has been transferred to the Batavia Police Department, which issued a statement about the case Sunday afternoon.
“Our thoughts and prayers go out to the family members of Sergeant Sanfratello and all the members of the Genesee County Sheriff’s Office at this extremely difficult time,” said Batavia Police Department Chief Shawn Heubusch.
The Sheriff's Office also released a statement expressing its deep regret and sorrow at Sanfratello's passing.
2013 File Photo/Booking Photo
The statement also stated, "Sergeant Sanfratello’s family would like to extend their sincere appreciation for all the overwhelming support they have received from friends and fellow first responders."
According to Heubusch, Sheriff's Sergeant Sanfratello and casino security were notified about an altercation inside the facility.
Heubusch said that Sanfratello and security were notified about 12:45 a.m. of a possible fight inside the casino. After an initial verbal confrontation inside Rush 34, Sanfratello and security staff began escorting two patrons from the facility.
The patrons are identified as Michael J. Elmore, 33, and Lyndsey Jean Wilcox, 39.
As they were escorted, Wilcox is accused of becoming physically combative with Sanfratello. With the assistance of security officers, Wilcox was restrained and placed under arrest.
At that point, Elmore allegedly interfered with her arrest and attacked Sanfratello.
Security officers and civilians attempted to assist Sanfratello. A fight ensued. Sanfratello attempted to use his taser to subdue Elmore but Elmore reportedly kept fighting.
During the fight, Sanfratello became unresponsive. People on scene began CPR.
The life-saving attempts were unsuccessful.
Heubusch said no further details are being released at this time.
Charges are expected against Elmore, according to Heuubusch. He did not elaborate.
Sanfratello began his law enforcement career as a dispatcher on Feb. 29, 1992. He was appointed deputy in 1996 and promoted to sergeant in 2007.
Gilmart Funeral Home and Cremation Company in Batavia is handling funeral arrangements. More information about funeral plans will be released later.
Elmore has a lengthy arrest recording. In 2009, he was accused of shooting a teen with a BB gun at the former skate park in Batavia. In 2012, he was charged with disorderly conduct following a fight on State Street. He was charged with a burglary at Sherwin-Williams in 2013. In 2015, he was accused of sending threatening texts to another person. He also has a prior history of tangling with law enforcement. He was charged with obstructing governmental administration during an incident in 2022 at the former Days Inn. In 2022, he was also accused of slashing tires on vehicles.
He served two years in state prison on the attempted burglary charge. His parole ended in 2021.
UPDATE: Henry Wojtaszek, CEO of Western Regional OTB, released the following statement:
The Batavia Downs Family is extremely saddened by the loss of Sergeant Sanfratello and we send our very deepest condolences to his family. We rarely have incidents at our facility in large part due to the incredible efforts of people like Sergeant SanFratello.
While words cannot express our sorrow, our thoughts and prayers are with the SanFratello family and his extended first responder family.
The safety of our guests and our dedicated staff is our highest priority, and we will continue to work with our partners in law enforcement throughout their investigation.
We are committed to assisting the SanFratello family and the entire community through this difficult time.
In an interview with The Batavian, Wojtaszek said that Batavia Downs began contracting with the Sheriff's Office four or five months ago to provide a security detail to the casino on Friday and Saturday nights. He said the arrangement is similar to what Batavia Downs does with Batavia PD and the Sheriff's Office during the summer concert series and that the agencies are compensated for the officers' time. He reiterated during the interview, "We are committed to the safety and security of our patrons."
UPDATE 6:05 p.m.: Heubusch said Elmore is in custody pending charges.
According to Heubusch, this is an ongoing investigation. Witnesses and people with video of the incident are asked to come forward. The Detective Bureau can be reached at 585-345-6311 or submit a tip at www.bataviapolice.org.
