Skip to main content

Today's Poll: Should the city seek state funding for Masse Gateway Project?

By Howard B. Owens
Charlie Mallow

Did you ever wonder why Batavia’s economy is so depressed?

We lack shovel ready land and the will to salvage our last bit of unused industrial land. The answer is not to let a huge area in the middle of the city disintegrate.

Apr 13, 2009, 8:46am Permalink
Peter O'Brien

No, the answer is to remove corporate taxes.

Let people keep more of what they earn, and then they will be interested in developing land without subsidies.

Apr 13, 2009, 9:09am Permalink
Charlie Mallow

You’re talking about a whole scale national change, that we in Batavia have no say in. We can only work within the system that we have. Its fine to take an ideological stand but, that doesn’t help us right here, right now.

Apr 13, 2009, 9:17am Permalink
Richard Gahagan

The real answer is that most of the larger industrial businesses left western New York a long time ago. The area is depressed because major corportations do not want be in New York, could it be taxes dare hey? Why should the government fund a large scale business project in an area that has been dying a slow economic death my entire life. Should the entire areas economy be solely dependent on government funding and everyone working for the government?

Apr 13, 2009, 9:54am Permalink
Mark Potwora

Look at Buffalo,were all the steel mills were tore down...Industrial land now open for develoment.No one is going there.Why would they come here to Batavia..

Apr 13, 2009, 10:14am Permalink
Charlie Mallow

Richard you’re getting no argument from me but, we still do live here and we can’t just give up. We will all grow old waiting for Albany to change.

Mark, take a good look around us, the area is growing. Just not here in the city because, there is no where to build.

I don’t see why we wouldn’t try to work within the system we now live in and just do the best we can with what we have. The only other option is to just move away. Let’s face it, that just is not choice most of us are going to make.

Apr 13, 2009, 10:22am Permalink
Howard B. Owens

I've no patience for defeatist attitudes. To do nothing is a sure way of ensuring continued decline and decay.

It's no secret I hate taxes and big government, but if the money doesn't come back to Batavia, it's just going to go else where. This isn't like the Mall where viable business are being torn down in favor of some wishy-washy notion of "progress."

It is probably unrealistic to expect businesses from out of state to relocate to WNY, but it's not unrealistic to expect to create an environment where ambitious local entrepreneurs can find a place to grow and thrive. And that's probably the weakest part of this proposal -- using the revolving loan fund to help this project lessens opportunity for entrepreneurs just when it's needed most.

Apr 13, 2009, 10:25am Permalink
Peter O'Brien

Well, good. Can I get some money from the government to start my business? My business will create one job but provide services for many.

Let me guess creating one job isn't enough to justify getting tax payer money. If that is the case, then how many is the right number? 5, 10, 1000?

If more people take a stand and get on politicians backs about handouts at every level, the government will finally be in the black and then we can demand money back in our pockets.

What happened to the American Entrepreneurial Spirit that wanted to owe no one anything when it came to their business so they could keep all that they made?

It's been nibbled away by years of entitlements and handouts and "He got this, why can't I" fairness attitude.

Fairness comes from equal opportunity to achieve, not results and until our country and state switch direction on this expect more handouts, more dependency and more taxes.

Apr 13, 2009, 12:18pm Permalink
Charlie Mallow

Of course you can get some money to start your own business. Every layer of government offers loans and grants; even the city offers small business loans. You need to have a business plan and be able to project out job creation in most cases. Some collateral doesn’t hurt either.

Just because we don’t like the system doesn’t mean we don’t have to live within it. I truly understand this ideology in a time of outright socialism and bailouts to the richest few. I don’t much like the idea of corporate welfare myself but, that is how business is done in this country and has been done for years. We either use our share of this state grant money or some other community will. Not taking our share doesn’t mean the money won’t be spent.

Apr 13, 2009, 1:05pm Permalink
Laura Russell Ricci

I believe that we should support our small businesses as well. Part of Batavia's problem is we are always looking back and not forward to where we are headed. Yeah Batavia and all of WNY are known as the Rust Belt, but there is no reason why we can't rally as citizens and change our perpective. Our community needs to INVEST in ourselves, with or without money from the State or Feds. I've always wanted to open a Bed and Breakfast in Batavia, and I'm asked, why would anyone travel to stay here? What are we doing as a city/community to bring people here?

Apr 13, 2009, 1:55pm Permalink
Mark Potwora

Charlie, If the city doesn't own this property ,why doesn't the property owner do this with one of those business loans you are talking about.If this is such a winning situation to attract new companies for Mr.Mancuso to rent to..Why does the city have apply for this,Why not Mr.Mancuso

Apr 13, 2009, 1:55pm Permalink
Charlie Mallow

Mark, This project is for building a road and demolishing a building to do it. Does it really matter who owns the property? Shouldn’t the city do what it needs to do to attract business and make use of dilapidated property? If we can raise the value of an industrial property from $800,000 to anywhere between $3-$5 Million dollars and thereby easing the tax burden on home owners, shouldn’t we?

Instead of continually talking about doing something to spur business in the city, shouldn’t we act? How many more years should we wait? We have tried doing NOTHING with that property for decades and that plan failed. What do we do now?

Apr 13, 2009, 2:09pm Permalink
Richard Gahagan

So can the city, state and feds run around knockin privately owned buildings down whenever they feel like it? Or is this just a service the government will now provide to property owners of big old nasty buildings that no one likes to look at anymore? If anything the government should pay to knock the the stinking mall that government money built after the government paid to knock down the city. Ah the hell with it knock the whole freakin place down and get outta there. Then the government can fund building cool stuff everwhere else.

Apr 13, 2009, 2:28pm Permalink
Charlie Mallow

Thanks Richard, so much for this conversation being fruitful. Yes, let’s knock down the city and then we can all move to Texas with you. Do you have a spare room we can all use till we get settled in?

Apr 13, 2009, 2:31pm Permalink
Gabor Deutsch

I am all for expansion not contraction. I would like to see medium to large business growth come out of it. Sure we have small businesses poping up all the time but some of them pop out before many people even realized they were there !

Apr 13, 2009, 3:20pm Permalink
Mark Potwora

Charlie..do we have any studies to back the fact up that Mr.Mancuso's assessment will go up and he will pay more in taxes..If that is fact then go for it...

Apr 13, 2009, 3:35pm Permalink
Howard B. Owens

Mark, are you going to be at the meeting tonight, or the public hearing on the 22nd? You raise good questions that should be asked in such a venue.

Apr 13, 2009, 3:39pm Permalink
Charlie Mallow

Mark, that is in the documentation and I will make sure of it before we go forward. Also, keep in mind this vote tonight is to set a public hearing. Questions at that hearing are welcome.

Apr 13, 2009, 4:00pm Permalink
John Roach

Federal and State stimulus money is already out there and there is nothing we can do about it, period. State and Federal tax policies that drive business out of NY and overseas are beyond our control here in Batavia. If we can get some of the stimulus money, fine. At least we get something for the future debt we have to pay off.

But we do not have any City money to spare. We have to put in thousands of city tax dollars for this grant, that we probably will never see back. And, we will have to borrow that money or raise property taxes just to get the money to give it away.

In addition to our City property tax money being given as a grant, our revolving loan fund for business will have to give up almost 50% of the fund balance for this. We are being asked to give loan money as a grant, why? Why not demand it be paid back with a set interest rate, with a set time limit and with a lien attached to the money?

This is a private business asking for my money and I don’t want to give away my money. The City is just starting to get out of debt after making a lot of bad decisions, and here we go again. Let the owners put there business up as security for this, it’s their property.

Apr 13, 2009, 6:31pm Permalink
Mike Del Plato

In the End,Mr.Thomas Mancuso gets his properties
spruced up.And if he gets any tennants?He'll fill his
pockets with rent money.It's a win-win situation for
him.And maybe for the city,I'm not sure?If we build it
will they,the businesses come?Hello,hello.Hello,hello.
Will it take down these "For Sale"signs in our city? Look at beautiful Dwyer Stadium,we can't even
fill that up and were paying for that.

Look,It's not just Batavia,Genesee county and New York.It's the whole counrty! Free trade! ,it"s destroying us! Till America wakes up,it's not going to matter.So if you tear it down and rebuild, you're not going to fill it.

Apr 14, 2009, 1:14am Permalink
Howard B. Owens

Actually, you do see Buffalo and Rochester spending tax money to aid private businesses. I don't follow the issues in those cities closely, but there's something about a sporting goods store in Buffalo and a couple of projects in Rochester that have gotten some scrutiny. In fact, you would be hard pressed to find any city in America that isn't using some sort of state or federal money for restoration and redevelopment projects, all in the name of creating jobs and improving the tax base.

In fact,businesses leaving New York isn't just a matter of NY's high taxes, historically, it's states like North Carolina and Tennessee offering huge tax breaks to businesses that relocate. A friend was recently telling me about a WNY business that years ago got big tax breaks to relocate to New Jersey, and then within a year it was out of business (all the long-time employees who really knew how to take care of things didn't relocate, and the young kids hired couldn't do the job).

I'm not really a fan of higher taxes that pay for all of these business improvements (lower taxes would have greater benefits), but so long as the system is as it is, and the money will get spent elsewhere if it isn't spent here, I can't really fault the local leaders for taking a stab at these grants. They didn't create the system and they can't change it. Until taxes are lowered and NY becomes a more business friendly state, programs like this at least offer some relief to municipalities looking to improve the situation.

One last thought: I've covered a lot of these government funded programs over the years. The ones that I've seen work try to make the best of structures already in place, and don't purposely dislocate existing businesses. The worst of them -- and Batavia's mall is a good example -- tear down existing businesses and try to bring in new, outside businesses. That never works out. Ever. In the Masse project, the buildings are mostly (completely?) vacant, and the only demolition taking place is to create better access from Main St. The project makes some sense. Only time will tell if it really works out.

Apr 14, 2009, 12:27am Permalink
Mike Del Plato

Hey Howie,
For your info,in Buffalo there tearing
down the old Aud.And it's own by the city,
it's not privately owned.Nothing going on
in Rochester either.
You stated better access from Main St.?
What's wrong with Swan St. and Harvester Ave.eh?

Apr 15, 2009, 10:59pm Permalink
Mike Del Plato

Hey Howie,
For your info,in Buffalo there tearing
down the old Aud.And it's own by the city,
it's not privately owned.Nothing going on
in Rochester either.

Apr 15, 2009, 12:09am Permalink
Mark Potwora

Better watch it Mike...Howard might claim all you want to do is Bitch and that you should go out and start your own business..You are so right..What is wrong with Swan and Harvester..Why do we need more access from Main St..

Apr 15, 2009, 12:41am Permalink
Mike Del Plato

Hey Beth,
For your info.,I don't know if you were watching the
the news back in Jan.Where PAETEC's stocks were
falling.And they were having second thoughts about the
Mid-town project.And those are businesses already
there.
And what happens to some businesses in the B.I.C
that are told that their rent is going up,When they move it to the newly rebuild B.I.C?Lay off or cut there
employees wages or pack up and leave?

Apr 15, 2009, 11:12pm Permalink
Beth Kinsley

I was watching the news Mike and am very well aware of what is happening at Midtown. My office looks directly at Midtown and I parked there for years until we all had to find other parking so that this project could move forward. My inconvenience is nothing compared to the businesses, a few of them thriving, that had to move out. I know that PAETEC has scaled down their plans due to the economy but hopefully, in the end, this will be a good thing for downtown.

Apr 16, 2009, 8:59am Permalink
Howard B. Owens

See, I just have a real problem with forcing businesses to move. I've never seen that work out, either for the redevelopment project or for the businesses force to relocate ... obviously some of them survive, but not many. I'm not a fan of eminent domain or other methods of essentially forcing private property owners to give up what should remain theirs.

Apr 16, 2009, 9:09am Permalink
Beth Kinsley

Agreed Howard but I think in this case, the owner was more than willing to get rid of it. It had been struggling for years along with the rest of downtown.

Apr 16, 2009, 9:20am Permalink
Mike Del Plato

First I thought Mancuso was getting $700,000.
Now it's 2.5 million? Where's that $700,000 going?
In his pocket? really.
Maybe we should of thought of this years ago.
We could've had Home Depot or BJ's on Mancusos'
property.At least we knew they were coming in
to Batavia.
F.Y.I Chris,This whole things a JOKE!
It's a bit too late,Batavias'behind
the times!

Apr 16, 2009, 2:48pm Permalink

Authentically Local