Local Matters

Community Sponsors

October 29, 2013 - 5:04pm

City Council at Large Candidate Questions for James Rosenbeck - Libertarian

posted by Bonnie Marrocco in city council, libertarian, James Rosenbeck.

There's a lot of concern from city residents about activities on Jackson and State Street. Do you consider those streets problem areas and if so, what should be done about them?

Yes, I do consider sections of Jackson Street and State Street problematic. Safe neighborhoods are a crucial priority for our city. I would add that there are other streets in the city that are also cause for concern. I support the use of regular police partner foot patrols in the most troubled neighborhoods. Given that we pay Genesee County taxes in addition to our city taxes, we should seek and utilize support from the Genesee County Sheriff's Department also.

What level of code enforcement do you favor to deal with seemingly problem properties?

I don't accept the premise that we should have different levels of code enforcement. If a property owner is in violation of city code, he/she should be afforded reasonable notice to rectify the violation or be cited as per the code.

How should garbage collection be handled in Batavia?

It is clear to me at this point  that the city does not need to be in the trash collection business or involved in any service that can be provided for effectively and efficiently by the private sector. Certainly, the city shouldn't be providing trash totes with tracking chips to local residents. Let's leave the trash tote business to the stores that sell them. Furthermore, I never quite understood how our cost for the use of a trash collection service should be connected to our property assessments.

Why should those owning homes of a higher assessed value be forced to subsidize the cost of garbage collection for those homeowners with lower assessments? Lets keep in mind that many of those higher valued homes, paying the biggest portion are our senior citizens living on fixed incomes. When the city taxpayer picks up the tab for trash removal we create a dis-incentive to recycling and subtly encourage less responsible management of solid waste. All that being said, my wife and I chose to remain customers of ARC. But, it was our choice. We believe in the mission of the agency. Choice improved the existing system and allowed people to tailor trash removal according to their specific needs.

I don't agree with the rhetoric about too many trucks on the streets and garbage piling up all over the city. The change in trash collection has promoted new businesses and employment opportunities. Competition and choice should be welcomed. Council candidates promising a return to a city run mandated trash service have neglected the reality that this would require voiding all of the private trash removal contracts currently in effect with local providers. Furthermore, those candidates should recognize and publicly acknowledge that they are running on a platform that if realized would likely put new trash service providers out of business.

What should be the city's role in economic and job development be in Batavia?

I do not support economic development corporations. Providing tax breaks and incentives for some while excluding others seems patently unfair. Growing bureaucracy in order to counteract the negative tax effects of an already too large and intrusive government seems counter intuitive. Whenever we as citizens give an unregulated EDC the power to grant financial favors we encourage cronyism and pay to play political patronage.

If the choice came down to either  A) raising taxes and maintaining the city's own police department and/or fire department; or, B) consolidating police protection with the city or going to some form of volunteer fire department, which option would you choose?

One need only look around the city and county to realize that we have far too many government owned buildings and too much duplication of services.The vision for the future has to be SHARED SERVICES. We do not have the luxury of raising taxes. Our city, surrounding towns and villages and the county of Genesee need to work cooperatively to share the expense for those services that are  important to our safety and well being. If I must choose, I choose option B.

Are you satisfied with how the city is run? Are there changes you would like to make? If you were going to change one thing about how the city operates, what would it be?

I believe that every single member of city council genuinely cares about our city. I don't feel they have all taken the opportunity to regularly communicate with voters and develop a shared vision for our future. City Council should be providing a vision, one crafted with direct input from the people. Our city manager's job is to provide the guidance and expertise to turn our shared vision into a plan for action. My observation in regularly attending council meetings is that too often the vision and direction is coming from the city manager to the council. We need more transparency and trust and less top down management at city hall.

Why did you decide to run for City Council?

I decided to run for City Council because I believe that we need new ideas on City Council. I don't profess that I have all the answers but I won't be afraid to ask questions. I bring a new libertarian perspective that isn't always shared by my democrat and republican friends.  But debate on the issues is healthy. I intend to offer people a responsive, transparent voice on city government. I am not a lifelong politician and I don't intend to become one. I run for City Council to be of service to a city I love, not for my own greater glory. I would appreciate your vote of support on November 5th and beyond.

Bill McDonald
Bill McDonald's picture
Last seen: 2 years 11 months ago
Joined: Oct 5 2008 - 10:28am

I don’t know much about politics and for the most part have never particularly cared... I do care about people and I do care about the community where I’ve chosen to reside, work and raise my family... During the last few years Jim Rosenbeck and I together have enjoyed our natural resourses, treasures, Genesee County Park, the mighty Tonawanda, numerous area bike trails, restaurants, entertainment venues, each of our homes, families and exercising ourselves and dogs… We have gotten to know each other well, shared good and tuff times. We’ve become great friends…

Jim in my opinion is a unique civic minded individual, who I trust and feel makes a difference. His family values are real and second to none; he has a genuine care and concern for everyone he comes in contact with… Jim opens up his arms to discussion and listens… Jim always has a solution and a sensible point of view, while treating everyone with respect and never in a confrontational way (he even listens to me…..)

Jim is in the running for one of three available seats on the city council in the November 2013 election.
I believe in his energetic ability to work with and for the people with a better community purpose in mind
I vote in every election and will do so in this one too…

Thank you for your time!
Bill McDonald

Carol Kay McMahon
Carol Kay McMahon's picture
Last seen: 4 years 2 months ago
Joined: Jan 15 2011 - 9:10am

We need to support Jim Rosenbeck for city council. I believe he is one who will help the citizens of Batavia in any way he can.

Brian Graz
Brian Graz's picture
Last seen: 9 hours 53 min ago
Joined: Sep 18 2010 - 4:57pm

How could any reasonable person fault the positions given here? I have been disenchanted for some time with the status quo of the 2 major parties and the partisan cronyism that pervades them both. I have always sought out the candidates that IMO are the best qualified to represent the needs and wants of the people 1st. I couldn't hope to find one with a vision and platform better than Jim Rosenbeck's.

Post new comment

Log in or register to post comments



Copyright © 2008-2019 The Batavian. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

blue button